Parmesan substitutes

The best substitute for parmesan is grana padano: 1:1.

Why it matters. A hard aged cheese packed with glutamates, so it seasons as much as it flavours. Grated on pasta it adds savoury depth and salt; stirred into a sauce its proteins add body. Traditional Parmigiano-Reggiano is made with animal rennet.

Substitutes

Best

grana padano

1:1

Made the same way and aged a little less, so it is milder and slightly less crystalline. Like Parmigiano-Reggiano it uses animal rennet.

pecorino romano

Use about 3/4 the amount

Sheep's milk, so it is sharper and considerably saltier. Scale it back and cut salt elsewhere in the dish. Made with animal rennet.

vegetarian italian-style hard cheese

1:1

Made with microbial rennet specifically so vegetarians can eat it. Very close on flavour and melting behaviour, though usually aged a little less.

aged asiago

1:1

Grates and melts similarly with a nuttier, slightly sweeter flavour. Young fresh Asiago is far too soft and will not work at all.

aged manchego

1:1

Comparable saltiness and it grates firmly, but the sheep's milk flavour is distinctly different and it melts less evenly into a sauce.

FAQ

What is the best substitute for parmesan?

The best substitute for parmesan is grana padano: 1:1. Made the same way and aged a little less, so it is milder and slightly less crystalline. Like Parmigiano-Reggiano it uses animal rennet.

Why does parmesan matter in a recipe?

A hard aged cheese packed with glutamates, so it seasons as much as it flavours. Grated on pasta it adds savoury depth and salt; stirred into a sauce its proteins add body. Traditional Parmigiano-Reggiano is made with animal rennet.

Can I use grana padano instead of parmesan?

1:1. Made the same way and aged a little less, so it is milder and slightly less crystalline. Like Parmigiano-Reggiano it uses animal rennet.

Can I use pecorino romano instead of parmesan?

Use about 3/4 the amount. Sheep's milk, so it is sharper and considerably saltier. Scale it back and cut salt elsewhere in the dish. Made with animal rennet.

Can I use vegetarian italian-style hard cheese instead of parmesan?

1:1. Made with microbial rennet specifically so vegetarians can eat it. Very close on flavour and melting behaviour, though usually aged a little less.

Can I use aged asiago instead of parmesan?

1:1. Grates and melts similarly with a nuttier, slightly sweeter flavour. Young fresh Asiago is far too soft and will not work at all.

Can I use aged manchego instead of parmesan?

1:1. Comparable saltiness and it grates firmly, but the sheep's milk flavour is distinctly different and it melts less evenly into a sauce.

All substitutes · Kitchen conversions

Last updated November 11, 2026.