Shortening substitutes
The best substitute for shortening is lard: 1:1.
Why it matters. One hundred percent fat with a high melting point and no water. That combination shortens gluten strands for very tender pastry and holds its shape, so cookies spread less and frosting stays stiff in warm rooms.
Substitutes
lard
1:1
Behaves almost identically and makes even flakier pastry, but it carries a faintly savoury flavour and it is not vegetarian.
butter
1 cup plus 2 tbsp butter per 1 cup shortening, and cut 2 tbsp of the recipe's liquid
Butter is about 16 percent water and melts far lower, so cookies spread more and hold their shape less. Pastry is flakier but noticeably less tender. The flavour is much better.
solid coconut oil
1:1, chilled firm
Solid at room temperature like shortening, but it melts at about 24C, so dough goes soft fast in a warm kitchen. Refined is flavourless; virgin tastes of coconut.
suet or beef tallow
1:1
A high melting point makes exceptionally short pastry and crisp pie crust, but it tastes savoury and it is not vegetarian.
block margarine
1:1
Contains water, so pastry is less tender and buttercream sets softer. Never use a tub spread, which has far more water again and will not hold structure at all.
FAQ
What is the best substitute for shortening?
The best substitute for shortening is lard: 1:1. Behaves almost identically and makes even flakier pastry, but it carries a faintly savoury flavour and it is not vegetarian.
Why does shortening matter in a recipe?
One hundred percent fat with a high melting point and no water. That combination shortens gluten strands for very tender pastry and holds its shape, so cookies spread less and frosting stays stiff in warm rooms.
Can I use lard instead of shortening?
1:1. Behaves almost identically and makes even flakier pastry, but it carries a faintly savoury flavour and it is not vegetarian.
Can I use butter instead of shortening?
1 cup plus 2 tbsp butter per 1 cup shortening, and cut 2 tbsp of the recipe's liquid. Butter is about 16 percent water and melts far lower, so cookies spread more and hold their shape less. Pastry is flakier but noticeably less tender. The flavour is much better.
Can I use solid coconut oil instead of shortening?
1:1, chilled firm. Solid at room temperature like shortening, but it melts at about 24C, so dough goes soft fast in a warm kitchen. Refined is flavourless; virgin tastes of coconut.
Can I use suet or beef tallow instead of shortening?
1:1. A high melting point makes exceptionally short pastry and crisp pie crust, but it tastes savoury and it is not vegetarian.
Can I use block margarine instead of shortening?
1:1. Contains water, so pastry is less tender and buttercream sets softer. Never use a tub spread, which has far more water again and will not hold structure at all.
All substitutes · Kitchen conversions
Last updated November 11, 2026.