Tahini substitutes

The best substitute for tahini is blended toasted sesame seeds: Blend 1 cup toasted hulled sesame seeds with 2 to 4 tbsp neutral oil until completely smooth.

Why it matters. Ground hulled sesame seeds. It brings bitter-nutty flavour and, crucially, emulsifies with water and lemon to make hummus and dressings creamy. Without it hummus is grainy and tastes only of chickpea.

Substitutes

Best

blended toasted sesame seeds

Blend 1 cup toasted hulled sesame seeds with 2 to 4 tbsp neutral oil until completely smooth

This is exactly what tahini is. Use hulled seeds, because unhulled ones make it harshly bitter, and expect about 5 minutes in a food processor.

sunflower seed butter

1:1

The best nut-free match on texture and mild bitterness, though sweeter. In a bake containing baking soda it can turn the crumb green, which is a colour change only, not spoilage.

black sesame paste

1:1

The same seed, more deeply toasted and much darker, so it will turn a pale hummus or dressing grey. Stronger and slightly more bitter.

cashew butter

1:1

Smooth and it emulsifies well, but it is sweeter and lacks tahini's bitterness, so hummus tastes flat and slightly cloying. Not nut-free.

almond butter

1:1, loosened with a little oil

Thicker and sweeter with an unmistakable almond flavour. It will stiffen a dressing unless you thin it. Not nut-free.

FAQ

What is the best substitute for tahini?

The best substitute for tahini is blended toasted sesame seeds: Blend 1 cup toasted hulled sesame seeds with 2 to 4 tbsp neutral oil until completely smooth. This is exactly what tahini is. Use hulled seeds, because unhulled ones make it harshly bitter, and expect about 5 minutes in a food processor.

Why does tahini matter in a recipe?

Ground hulled sesame seeds. It brings bitter-nutty flavour and, crucially, emulsifies with water and lemon to make hummus and dressings creamy. Without it hummus is grainy and tastes only of chickpea.

Can I use blended toasted sesame seeds instead of tahini?

Blend 1 cup toasted hulled sesame seeds with 2 to 4 tbsp neutral oil until completely smooth. This is exactly what tahini is. Use hulled seeds, because unhulled ones make it harshly bitter, and expect about 5 minutes in a food processor.

Can I use sunflower seed butter instead of tahini?

1:1. The best nut-free match on texture and mild bitterness, though sweeter. In a bake containing baking soda it can turn the crumb green, which is a colour change only, not spoilage.

Can I use black sesame paste instead of tahini?

1:1. The same seed, more deeply toasted and much darker, so it will turn a pale hummus or dressing grey. Stronger and slightly more bitter.

Can I use cashew butter instead of tahini?

1:1. Smooth and it emulsifies well, but it is sweeter and lacks tahini's bitterness, so hummus tastes flat and slightly cloying. Not nut-free.

Can I use almond butter instead of tahini?

1:1, loosened with a little oil. Thicker and sweeter with an unmistakable almond flavour. It will stiffen a dressing unless you thin it. Not nut-free.

All substitutes · Kitchen conversions

Last updated November 11, 2026.